Competitor Research DeskSample decision reportChecked 9 Nov 2026
Packaging a $19 transactional email add-on
We sell an email-marketing product to small SaaS teams. Should we launch a transactional add-on at $19 a month with 10,000 emails and one sending domain?
The bottom line
The $19 price is inside the $15 to $20 range these vendors charge for 10,000 emails a month. The one-domain limit is the problem: Postmark includes five sending domains for $15 and Resend includes ten for $20, while the only plan as restrictive, Mailgun Basic, costs $4 less than the proposal.
Our recommendation
Do not launch with a one-domain limit. Test $19 with at least five sending domains, and decide what “history” means (delivery logs or stored messages) before you set a retention period. Treat $19 as a hypothesis until your cost floor and buyer response are known.
Confidence: Medium. Prices and plan limits are published and current for all three vendors at this volume. Public sources cannot show what your buyers will pay, your cost floor or delivery quality.
Key numbers
- $15–$20Monthly cost of 10,000 emails on the three vendors’ entry plans Sources:
- 5 domainsIncluded with Postmark Basic at $15. The proposal includes one at $19. Sources:
- $35Mailgun’s price once a customer needs a second sending domain (Foundation) Sources:
- 13,000Emails a month at which Resend’s flat $20 becomes the cheapest of the three Sources:
1 Numbered counters open the dated capture behind a fact.Numbered counters match the entries in the Source register.
= Tables and notes show our arithmetic from those facts.
! Recommendations and verdicts are our judgment.
Options weighed
Comparable numbers
What $15 to $20 buys at 10,000 emails a month
| Plan | Price / month | Emails included | Sending domains | History | Extra 1,000 emails |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Your proposed add-on | $19.00 | 10,000 | 1 | Not decided | Not decided |
| Postmark Basic | $15.00 | 10,000 | 5 | 45-day data retention | $1.80 Sources: |
| Mailgun Basic | $15.00 | 10,000 | 1 | 1-day logs | From $1.80 Sources: |
| Postmark Pro | $16.50 | 10,000 | 10 | 45 days, extendable to 365 | $1.30 Sources: |
| Postmark Platform | $18.00 | 10,000 | Unlimited | 45 days, extendable to 365 | $1.20 Sources: |
| Resend Pro | $20.00 | 50,000 | 10 | 30-day data retention | $0.90 Sources: |
| Mailgun Foundation | $35.00 | 50,000 | 1,000 | 5-day logs, 1-day messages | From $1.30 Sources: |
Monthly cost in three usage scenarios
| Vendor | Baseline: 10,000 emails, 1 domain | Peak month: 15,000 emails, 1 domain | Multi-brand: 10,000 emails, 8 domains |
|---|---|---|---|
| Resend | $20.00 (Pro) | $20.00 (Pro) | $20.00 (Pro) Sources: |
| Postmark | $15.00 (Basic) | $23.00 (Pro: $16.50 + 5 × $1.30) | $16.50 (Pro) Sources: |
| Mailgun | $15.00 (Basic) | From $24.00 (Basic: $15 + 5 × $1.80) | $35.00 (Foundation) Sources: |
| Your proposed add-on | $19.00 | Overage not decided | Not offered (1 domain) |
Entry price at 10,000 emails, with the domains each plan includes
How each competitor packages it
Resend
- Pricing
- Pro: $20 a month for 50,000 emails, then $0.90 per 1,000. The free plan is capped at 100 emails a day, so it cannot serve these scenarios.
- Packaging
- Pro includes 10 custom domains and 30 days of data retention. Marketing email is a separately priced product.
Sources:
Postmark
- Pricing
- At 10,000 emails: Basic $15.00, Pro $16.50 and Platform $18.00 a month. Extra 1,000 emails cost $1.80, $1.30 and $1.20.
- Packaging
- Five, ten and unlimited sending domains. 45 days of data retention by default; Pro and Platform can extend it up to 365 days.
Sources:
Mailgun
- Pricing
- Basic starts at $15 a month for 10,000 emails, with extra emails from $1.80 per 1,000. Foundation is $35 a month for 50,000 after a free first month, with extra emails from $1.30 per 1,000.
- Packaging
- Basic: one custom sending domain and one day of log retention. Foundation: 1,000 domains, five days of logs and one day of message retention.
Sources:
What the evidence says
A second sending domain costs nothing extra on Postmark’s or Resend’s entry plans, but moves a Mailgun customer from $15 to $35. Sources:
Above 10,000 emails the cheapest plan changes: at 15,000, Postmark Pro ($23.00) beats Postmark Basic ($24.00) because its overage is $0.50 cheaper per 1,000. Sources:
From 13,000 emails a month, Resend’s flat $20 (50,000 included) is the lowest price of the three in our arithmetic. A 10,000-email allowance looks small against that. Sources:
Each vendor describes history differently: Postmark 45 days of data retention, Resend 30 days, Mailgun Basic one day of logs. Decide whether the add-on keeps logs or full messages before you price it. Sources:
Mailgun publishes overage as a starting rate (“from $1.80 per 1,000”), so its 15,000-email cost is a floor, not a quote. Sources:
For the pricing meeting
Pushback you are likely to hear, and what the sources say.
- “Mailgun sells one domain for $15, so one domain is normal.”
Mailgun Basic does, with one day of logs and a jump to $35 when a customer needs a second domain. Postmark Basic includes five domains at the same $15. One domain is the low end of this market, not its norm.
Sources:
- “Resend charges $20, so $19 undercuts the market.”
Only on the headline. Resend’s $20 includes 50,000 emails and ten domains; the proposal includes 10,000 and one. Against Resend, $19 buys less.
Sources:
- “We can sell extra domains later as an upsell.”
You can, but competitors have already set the reference points: Postmark’s ten-domain plan is $16.50, and Mailgun’s first plan with more than one domain is $35. An upsell priced against those steps is easier to defend than a one-domain launch.
Sources:
- “How current are these prices?”
Every figure links to the vendor’s public pricing page and was checked on 9 November 2026. Re-check before you publish your own price.
Sources:
What to do next
Check your cost floor
Model sending, storage, support and abuse-handling costs for 10,000 emails across five domains. Competitor list prices are not your unit economics.
Test the constrained choice
Show target buyers the five-domain package beside the one-domain version and ask which job the extra domains solve. A favorable comment is not a purchase.
Define history before pricing it
Choose between delivery logs and stored message content, then set the retention period. The vendors’ labels are not interchangeable.
Assumptions and limits
Assumptions
- Outbound transactional email only, with no inbound volume.
- Volumes in whole thousands, so partial overage blocks do not change the totals.
- Self-serve list prices in USD before tax; no negotiated discounts, trials, promotions, dedicated IPs or other add-ons.
- For each vendor, the lowest-cost reviewed plan that meets the scenario’s volume and domain needs.
What this report does not establish
This report compares published prices and plan limits. It does not measure deliverability, support quality, migration effort or what your buyers will pay. Postmark’s higher-volume tiers and Mailgun’s account-specific overage rates were not verified, so Mailgun’s overage appears as a starting rate. Vendor prices can change after the dates shown.
Source register
Every source behind the numbers above, with the date it was checked. Vendor prices change; re-check before you publish your own.
1Resend pricing (official Markdown version)
Pro | $20/mo | 50,000 | $0.90 … The Free plan is limited to 100 emails per day. … Custom domains: Pro 10 … Data retention: Pro 30 days
Higher Pro volume tiers are not needed for these scenarios. Only the captured terms shown here are used in the calculations.
Basic $15.00 /mo … Starting at 10,000 emails/month. Extra emails @ $1.80 / 1,000 … 45-day data retention · 5 Custom sending domains. Pro $16.50 /mo … $1.30 / 1,000 … 10 Custom sending domains. Platform $18.00 /mo … $1.20 / 1,000 … Unlimited Custom sending domains.
Only the default 10,000-email selection was verified. Higher-volume slider tiers are excluded rather than inferred.
Basic: starting at $15/mo · 10,000 emails/mo · 1 custom sending domain · 1 day log retention · from $1.80 / 1,000 emails. Foundation: free for 1 month, then $35/mo · 50,000 emails/mo · 1,000 domains · 5 days log retention · 1 day message retention · from $1.30 / 1,000 emails.
Prices exclude the free first month. Overage figures use Mailgun’s published starting rate; confirm your rate before choosing a plan.
Captured 9 Nov 2026
Source 1: Resend pricing (official Markdown version)
resend.com/pricing.md
Pro | $20/mo | 50,000 | $0.90 … The Free plan is limited to 100 emails per day. … Custom domains: Pro 10 … Data retention: Pro 30 days
Captured 9 Nov 2026
Source 2: Postmark pricing
postmarkapp.com/pricing
Basic $15.00 /mo … Starting at 10,000 emails/month. Extra emails @ $1.80 / 1,000 … 45-day data retention · 5 Custom sending domains. Pro $16.50 /mo … $1.30 / 1,000 … 10 Custom sending domains. Platform $18.00 /mo … $1.20 / 1,000 … Unlimited Custom sending domains.
Captured 9 Nov 2026
Source 3: Mailgun Send pricing
mailgun.com/pricing
Basic: starting at $15/mo · 10,000 emails/mo · 1 custom sending domain · 1 day log retention · from $1.80 / 1,000 emails. Foundation: free for 1 month, then $35/mo · 50,000 emails/mo · 1,000 domains · 5 days log retention · 1 day message retention · from $1.30 / 1,000 emails.